Declaratory Relief in CERCLA Actions

The Ninth Circuit today held that a CERCLA plaintiff that fails to prove liability for recoverable response costs may not obtain declaratory relief for future response costs that it may incur. In City of Colton v. American Promotional Events, Inc., the Ninth Circuit first affirmed summary judgment for defendants on plaintiff's claims for responses costs because plaintiff had admittedly not complied with the National Contingency Plan. The court then held, in a case of first impression in the Ninth Circuit, that plaintiff was not entitled to declaratory relief for future costs.

-Morgan